
Blog
Do You Need Approval to Replace a Roof in Lawyers Hill, Elkridge, MD?
A new roof that matches the old one exactly needs no review in Lawyers Hill. A different material or look needs approval first. Here is how the district guidelines draw the line.
Sometimes. If your house is in the Lawyers Hill Historic District in Elkridge and the new roof matches the old one exactly, the district's design guidelines call that routine maintenance and no Certificate of Approval is needed. If the new roofing does not exactly match what is there, the work needs approval from Howard County before it starts.
This post is about the approval, not the job. If you are weighing a roofing company in Elkridge, Diakite Roofing & Restoration is based in Columbia and replaces roofs across Howard County, and our page on roof replacement in Elkridge covers how the job itself runs. For the county's other local district, see our post on roof replacement rules in historic Ellicott City.

What roofs do Lawyers Hill houses have?
The guidelines say the original roof materials in Lawyers Hill include slate, standing seam metal and wood shingles. On many houses the original roofing has since been replaced with composition (asphalt) shingles, which the guidelines call one of the most common roofing materials in the district. Most houses have gabled roofs. Flatter roofs, such as shed roofs over porches and additions, are common too, gambrel roofs appear on the Dutch Colonial and Colonial Revival houses, and the guidelines count one saltbox, a tenant house built in 1900.
So two roofs on the same street can be in different situations. One still carries its original material, which the guidelines say to repair rather than replace. The other has already been re-roofed in asphalt.
When does a Lawyers Hill roof need a Certificate of Approval?
The roof section of the guidelines and their summary of activities requiring a certificate give these answers:
| Work on the roof | Certificate of Approval? |
|---|---|
| Repairing the roof with material similar to the existing roofing in size, color and texture | No, routine maintenance |
| Replacing the roofing with new material that exactly matches the original | No, routine maintenance |
| Replacing gutters and downspouts with a similar size, location and finish, in the same color or one consistent with the walls | No, routine maintenance |
| Replacing exterior materials with new ones that do not exactly match the existing | Yes |
| Adding a new feature to the building, such as a dormer | Yes |
| Replacing the roofing on an outbuilding that cannot be seen from public roads or neighboring houses | No if the outbuilding is under 50 years old, Yes if it is over 50 |
Rows follow the Lawyers Hill Historic District Design Guidelines, chapter 6 section H and Appendix A. County staff decide your own plan.
What if the original roofing cannot be matched?
The guidelines recommend keeping the original roofline and repairing rather than replacing a roof that still has its original material. When the original roofing has to be replaced, they say to use material similar to the original or characteristic of the building's period and style, particularly if the roof can be seen from a public street or is a key part of the building's character. They add that modern materials such as composition shingles may be approved if historically accurate roofing cannot reasonably be required for economic or other reasons.
Two things the guidelines list as not recommended: replacing roofing with materials that significantly alter the structure's appearance, and installing skylights on a primary elevation or anywhere visible from a public road.
The guidelines also say they are not regulations. They frame the Commission's review and leave room for individual solutions. That is why a different shingle on a historic roof is a conversation with county staff before it is a purchase order.
Who do you ask, and when?
Howard County's Department of Planning and Zoning staffs the Historic Preservation Commission and processes applications for certificates. The county's Historic Preservation Commission page carries the Lawyers Hill design guidelines. The guidelines were adopted on April 6, 1995, and rules get updated, so read the current version.
A change that needs a certificate needs it before the crew starts, so the question belongs at the start of a replacement, not in the middle of one. Interior alterations do not need a Certificate of Approval, so work inside the house sits outside this review.
How do we plan a roof in Lawyers Hill?
It starts with a free roof inspection. Lassana Diakite walks the roof himself, photographs every slope, the valleys and the flashing at each chimney, dormer and wall, and shows you the photos before anyone talks about price. Those photos and our written scope show a reviewer what is on the roof today, and you can attach them to an application.
The scope names the shingle. On our replacements that is an Owens Corning architectural shingle, and a full replacement includes 100 feet of gutter, gutter guard and downspouts. If your house still has slate, standing seam metal or wood shingles and the review points toward matching them, tell us before the inspection so we can say plainly whether it is a job we take. We work Monday through Saturday, 8am to 5pm.
Sources: Howard County, Lawyers Hill Historic District Design Guidelines (adopted April 6, 1995), chapter 6 section H, Roofs, Gutters and Downspouts, and Appendix A, Summary of Activities Requiring a Certificate of Approval; Howard County Historic Preservation Commission page. Read November 11, 2026. County rules change, so confirm your plan with county staff before you sign a contract. This is general information, not legal advice.
Related reading
For where Elkridge leaks tend to start, see roof repair in Elkridge. For how old Elkridge's roofs are, see roof inspection in Elkridge. For the Ellicott City district, see roof replacement rules in historic Ellicott City.
Old house in Elkridge?
We inspect the roof for free, photograph every slope and write a scope you can show county staff.